« 'Each episode, he gets uglier. It's amazing.' | Main | The Bloggies 2007: For Your Consideration »

Jan 07, 2007

'Brain transfers are a really stupid idea.'

LucieUnsurprisingly, this review contains a few spoilers so don't read it unless you've heard 'Blood of the Daleks' first.  I'll just reassure you that once again, it's really, really good and you should go here and listen to it here if you haven't already or you're waiting for the cd.

Who is the mysterious Mr. Halburt and what does he want with Lucie Miller?

Unlike the television versions, Doctor Who spin-offs have always been good at plot arcs.  Whereas the Key To Time Season was handstrung by telling essentially the same story four or six times, in the first few seasons of the McGann audios, the problem of Charley Pollard become heart rendering and in the books the amnesiac Doctor, stuck on earth for nearly a century was a fertile ground for stories and mysteries and cultural investigation.

The arc in this new BBC7 series has begun.  Lucie and The Doctor are very much stuck together by the timelords, he apparently hiding or protecting her after she's witnessed something unknown - that much was apparent from Part One.  Now, a Mr. Halburt has engaged the services of someone called the Headhunter (played with a sinister professionalism by Big Finish stalwart Katarina Olsson), an apparent bounty hunter with the facility to travel all time and space, to find the reluctant companion. 

It's all very mysterious, all very Lost, but unlike the Bad Wolf scenario were anything was possible and the reveal was inevitably going to be disappointing, this has very specific parameters, and turns this whole season into a chase and it's going to be really fun as the clues are revealed over the coming weeks as to what the Northerner saw, why the timelords want to hide her, and the connect with their antagonist.

But that's for the future.  Tonight's concluding part of Blood of the Daleks was an eclectic mix of traditional and nu-Who, authentic enough to have the announcer give a recap beforehand (which if this had been television would have no doubt featured on-set photos of the cast looking at something far off) but with the contemporary spin on the Doctor's arch foes seen in the new series - they fly and say 'Elevate!' as they're doing so.

After the setting up of the world and the tragedy in the opening part, this was the Dalek heavy end of the story, with Nick Briggs doing over time on the ring modulator to create a cast of hundreds.

Hayleyatwell1 After the setting up of the world and the tragedy in the opening part, this was the Dalek heavy end of the story, with Nick Briggs doing over time on the ring modulator to create a cast of hundreds.  Perhaps knowing that this story was to be heard by a much wider audience than something like the Dalek Empire stories, writer Steve Lyons concocted a straightforward meat and potatoes plot riffing on Genesis of the Daleks or Spare Parts, in which a proto-Davros, Martez (a chillingly clinical Hayley Atwell, pictured), living beyond his own execution in the body of one of his young female lab assistants was employing a crashed ship from Skaro to breed a new race using the inhabitants of his world, Red Rocket Rising, as fodder.

Unsurprisingly, the classic Daleks decided that these new boys weren't pure enough and set about trying to eradicate them, and in a twist I loved, the Doctor was helping them.  Seems that he always regretted not using the right all of those centuries ago and wanted to nip this genesis in the bud, "I had chance like this before", he says, "and I chose not to take it.  Big mistake."  This was catharsis for him and it revealed a much darker streak in the Eighth Doctor than we've seen before (well since the whole Zagreus thing), deciding that it's a perfectly viable option to use one evil to destroy potentially an even greater one.  Even after all these years, the Daleks still have the capacity to push buttons -- whenever they talked about racial purity, a chill went down my back.

If this had been made for television the result would have been Dalek porn

If this had been made for television the result would have been Dalek porn, as the two factions went to war, with the tiny human colony jammed in the middle, their ravaged world becoming a shell.  If last week the story resembled the BBC's Day of the Triffids, this had all the hallmarks of Spielberg's War of the Worlds with the Doctor and everyone else dodging in and out of buildings trying to escape the carnage.  The atmospheric sound design here has a much greater depth than most Big Finish production, with one scene in which the Doctor and Lucie viewed the first meeting of the two factions from the top window of a building being particularly potent.  The score too was far more apparent, with a lovely use of the strings to punctuate the catastrophe.

Daleks_3 Inevitably, comparisons can be made with the new television series, with the mass Dalek army flying through the air, despite apparently being the classic models according to the cd box of the first episode, probably looking exactly like similar scenes in Doomsday.  The resolution too smacked of The Age of Steel, but the final end to the conflict, fittingly for audio, was more to do with the Doctor's persuasive powers rather than some massive explosion.  The theme of parallel development was repeated here too.  I remember wondering, watching that mid-second season two parter what it would be like if the Telos Cybermen actually ever fought the parallel Earth versions and I imagine the results would have been something like this - although given that the former frequently couldn't walk or shoot straight and took ages to build a bomb the contest might not have been as even handed as this.

In this month's Doctor Who Magazine, in reviewing the opening episode, Matt Michael noted that unlike Rose, there wasn't much time set aside for the listener to get a handle of Lucie, for us to love her.  I'd dispute that this is actually too important, and that unlike Rose, we're seeing the adventure largely from the Doctor's point of view - she's actually part of whatever the problem he's dealing with.  Lucie had less to do in this episode and yet she was still given that moment which all companions seem to have, when dealing with Tom Cardwell (whom I'd marked for death but turned into something of a heroic figure)  and his explosive batteries, when they realise that whatever the Doctor is doing must be right and they should be doing everything they can to help him.

I'd love to know what the kids listening to this are making of this version a character, so huggable on screen, so aggravated on radio.

The reason I like her, apart from Sheridan Smith's delicious performance is that she's actually bringing out a new side to the Eighth Doctor.  I'd love to know what the kids listening to this are making of this version a character, so huggable on screen, so aggravated on radio.  I don't think he laughed for this entire fifty minutes except in mockery, and he's no doubt got a permanent scowl which says 'the timelords have bloody gone and done it to me again'.  As I said last week, and I'll probably to continue to keep saying, the chemistry between the two actors and so characters is brilliant - it's like someone has taken Clarke Gable and Claudette Colbert's characters from Frank Capra's It Happened One Night and dropped them in a Tardis together.  Sort of.  The Doctor's less charming than Gable, but you get the idea.  Screwball.  As in comedy.

But what I really love about this is that it isn't afraid to drop in continuity references - it fits within the classic series more fluidly.  In one exchange, the Doctor wonders if the Daleks were fighting the Movellans, the Mechanoids or each other and there's a lovely twist at the very end, in which Anita Dobson's vacant President Klint reveals that the woes of the Red Rock Rising aren't entirely over - some change from an arena in which just saying G-word is a major event.  Only a fan though would also still be stressing about were in the Eighth Doctor's timeline this is set; according to the Gallifrey spin-off the Doctor was still in the divergent universe in the closing episode in which case the timelords are all but destroyed.  In which case this might be happening before Storm Warning, but that doesn't seem right either.  Any ideas?

Next Week:  The Tardis lands for the first time properly in the year of my birth.  Scary.


The final moments of the Daleks & "daleks" reminded me of the first Doctors "Even if I wanted to I don't know how" line from the first Dalek story.

I laughed at the president repeating her mistake all over again with the saviours from Telos. This woman proves the DNA maxim, "anyone who is capable of getting themselves elected as President, should on no account be allowed to do the job".

Is she some distant descendent of Susan who took gullability a new level with the Dalek olive branch to the Thals?

Just listened to the second part last evening, great stuff. Was chuckling to myself at the Doctor's Dalek impression "FISH AND CHIPS FOR ALL!" It was Red Rocket Rising rather than "Rock" wasn't it? Nick Briggs story in the documentary about scaring the little boy with his ring modulator was pretty funny as well.

Thanks for the pick up. Fixed it.

It is probably set well after the Gallifrey Audios. The Time Lords probably didn't know (as of those audios) that the Doctor came back, being wrapped up as they were in civil war at the time (They weren't totally wiped out in that audio, Braxiatel said they might be later on due to what was coming [i.e. Daleks].) Obviously they know now.

Also Blood of the Daleks has some fascinating implications which help to place it chronologically. We know the Daleks are at war with someone, but the issue of who is always dodged (it's probably the Time Lords.)

Lucie is from the North and even says "Fantastic" at one point near the end of the story.

Given how the 10th Doctor imprinted on Rose and gained a Cockney accent of sorts, we can see here a potential for imprinting again, which might explain the 9th Doctor's accent and catchphrase.

Taking all this into account I'd have to put this story solidly in the beginning or middle stages of the Time War. I have a feeling these BBC audios are going to try a bit of gap-filling...

Dr Xaduim raises some interesting points, and it's also nice to see someone else who's listened to the Gallifrey audios(is Braxietel not the greatest?). I especially like the imprinting bit.

Hmmm imprinting kina makes sense but thank god we never saw this

Grace: I put us into a temporal orbit
Eighth Doctor: Wicked!

I also felt that "Fish & chips for all" was very Seventh.

HAHAHA I love the idea of Ace imprinting on the Doctor. Erhm, well, love it and hate it. Well, more hate it. But love it in a "maybe if BBV did it, so therefore it wasn't canon" sorta way. And yeah, I've heard The Time Travellers series.

Best. Audio. Ever.

God, how I miss McGann - a proper, non-smug Doctor with a great sense of humour and oddles of danger bubbling underneath; he sounded like he was having a ball. I loved the fractious relationship with Lucie too - I hope this will be similar to the forthcoming Martha/Doc dynamic in Season 3. Some superb one-liners ("This Doctor is a bit rubbish!"), a great, pacey plot and a brilliant, side-splitting twist: "They come from Tel....". And the Time Lord witness protection angle has me gagging for more. Great stuff. Roll on next week...

Neil -- I'm glad you liked it too. Steve Lyons has always been one of my favourite Who writers -- his book The Witch Hunters is the best Hartnell historical we never had. He's always so authentic and seems to get the format which ever era he's writing in. Plus he's not afraid to drop in continuity references and jokes and seem to do it in such a controlled way -- unlike some. I'm glad these audios are vindicating my ongoing choice of Eighth as my favourite Doctor.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Doctor Who: Series One
Doctor Who: Series Two
Doctor Who: Series Three
Torchwood: Series One
Torchwood: Series Two
The Sarah Jane Adventures: Series One
The Eighth Doctor BBC7 Audios
The Eighth Doctor Novels
The Tenth Doctor Novels
Stripped Down Series 1
Stripped Down Series 2
Stripped Down Series 3
Stripped Down Series 4
Stripped Down Series 5
Stripped Down Series 6