« 10/2=5 + (30,528Km2) = Time Crash | Main | When Doctors Collide »

Nov 16, 2007

Maynard Undead

As soon as it started I felt privileged to be a Doctor Who fan.  Sir Guy of Gisbourne was stalking menacingly around Nottingham Castle again and it was all to do with whomever Maid Marion has been spending her time with.  Strangely the appearance of Pudsey Bear was less anachronistic than it might have been considering everyone else in that version of the twelfth century seems to have been to the John Lewis sale for their make-up and costumes.  You do have to feel sorry for the Robin Hood fans who have to content themselves with a non-canonical skit, albeit with a cute wink from the lovely Lucy Griffiths and the sight of Guy almost hanging a stuffed bear.

Not for them a musical lead in from Myleene ‘full of’ Klass and John ‘full of’ Barrowman (far preferable to the Jordan and Andre suck fest from last time which some of us still have to endure if we want to hear the proper cloister bell).  Not for them a Radio Times cover and mention in the listings, a canonical story which brings back a well loved incarnation from the past, written by the man who brought us the best episode of the last series.   Not for them a whole five minutes dropped in to the mayhem, instead their mini-episode wrapped around some shambling on some stairs with Wogan menacing a school boy for some cash.  Kind of makes you feel like tv fan royalty.

The script for Time Crash was vintage Steven Moffat; funny, exciting and touching and enveloped around a time travel related conceit.   

The script for Time Crash was vintage Steven Moffat; funny, exciting and touching and enveloped around a time travel related conceit.  In fact, it was the same kind of paradoxical causality loop we saw in Blink, in which the Doctor could only follow the plan that Sally had already passed on to him in the folder.  And so Tenth knew how to fix the Tardis because he’d already seen it as Fifth, even though neither of them had experienced the brainwave.  Of course it does beg the question how he then forgot about telling himself about the return of the Master (and his wife) but that information was probably lost in one of the Eighth Doctor’s several spells of amnesia so we’ll forgive him.  That should sort out problems with The Five Doctors too.  Oh how we wish that the series had been this well written back then.

I think Time Crash was about as good as we could have hoped it would be, ultimately ignoring many of our expectations and doing something better.  Whereas I’d expected some veiled reference to Dimensions in Time and the emotional journey being the fact that Tenth couldn’t tell Fifth about the time war (which I do hope they’re saving for the extravaganza with the Eighth Doctor which my fan gene expects this was a precursor to) this was about what is to be a fan, in an even more direct way than Love and Monsters (Fifth’s heard of LINDA!  Yay, LINDA!), and more specifically a fan of David Tennant’s generation for whom Peter Davison was their Doctor and who we (because he was really – I just say Paul McGann because I like looking at raised eyebrows).   Even the title must be a riff on a certain story recently released on dvd featuring a supersonic aircraft and the Master in a rubbish, sorry, rubber mask).

Fifth’s heard of LINDA!  Yay, LINDA!

All of the continuity references!  As well as affectionately ripping the piss out of the Peter Davison era, with its synthesiser music (nice one Murray 'err um' Gold), spectacles, the hands free, rubbish beards, funny hats and decorative vegetables, David got to say things like Nyssa and Tegan and the Mara (but not Adric or Turlough) as though remembering when he was pulled out of history and we remembered with him (even if it suggested a placement for Fifth as just after Snakedance which means we’re remember Martin Clunes in make-up (boxset with Kinda due next year then). 

And wasn’t Peter Davison good?  When the new show was being cast, way before we were waiting for Christopher, I suggested that Pete should be given another go at it.  I can see why that didn’t happen (see Russell's comments on older actors from Project Who), but he’s  really grown into the role.  Often maligned because his television era only really brought us about four unequivocally good stories, he himself has admitted it wasn’t until Caves of Andronzani that he really understood how to play the Doctor and that certainly shows in his Big Finish stories from which I think you can see some continuity here – the grumpiness is definitely a carry over as well as the gruff.

Tennant was certainly at the apogee of his Tennantness

Davison's was a very gracious performance, essentially providing something for the current incumbent to bounce off.  Tennant was certainly at the apogee of his Tennantness, but that just heightened the differences between them even as he listed the similarities.  For all Russell’s bluff about taking Terry Dick’s opinion that the Doctor stays the same and it’s whatever the actor brings to the role, he does spend a lot of time making observations, making fun, turning on a dime in a crisis and shouting which are things that Davison’s Doctor rarely did.  Not that he had much time with all the bickering. 

It’s a shame that Graham Harper didn’t receive an on-screen credit here since his work here was superb, never once letting the camera rest too long anywhere – loads of energy and whatnot, always keeping the two Doctors in the same frame underlining their connection.  Tucking the story into the end of The Last of the Timelords worked well too and unlike the Pudsey Cutaway, you really couldn’t see the join, well not with these old eyes.  Except the colours in the Tardis seemed much richer to me, the lighting emphasizing the yellows and greens highlighting the two costumes. 

Were they really Peter’s old cricket whites?  That stick of celery looked far too healthy …

Comments

The BBC site says Peter's trousers were the ones made for Colin at the end of Caves. Also, the celery was plastic back then, and this was obviously replaced in this version.

The join wasn't visible, but Tennant pointed something out in LoTTL commentary about it. Brilliant. Also nice explanation as to how Titanic meets TARDIS!

I see you didn't mention the "desktop theme" line :)

"Of course it does beg the question how he then forgot about telling himself about the return of the Master (and his wife) but that information was probably lost in one of the Eighth Doctor’s several spells of amnesia so we’ll forgive him. "

..Or perhaps the Doctor thought his future self had been referring to the Eric Roberts incarnation? After all, he did lack a beard and have a wife.

According to the associated Doctor Who Confidential, most of the costume was nicked off the Blackpool exhibition. The jumper and celery were new, and the trousers were the ones Colin Baker had to have tailored for himself in Caves.

Thanks for the costume explanation. I didn't mention the desktop thing because I didn't want to mention everything. Although I nearly called the review Blue Screen of Death which I've always thought would make a great knowing Doctor Who title ...

Just re-watched it. Superb! It's left me wondering this;

Will the Christmas Special start by showing the TARDIS crashing into the TARDIS? If yeah, will we hear Peter's final words again? Hope so :)

I would think a rehash of Christmas Invasion, assume everyone is upto speed & launch straight in.

Loved the whole event even if did seem to be directed against the Fifth (Classic series) until the last 3 minutes, which more then made up for any perceived injustice.

"You were my doctor."
Damnit. Something in my eye... *sniff*

"His television era only really brought us about four unequivocally good stories."

What show were you watching mate?

More like his era only gave us four stories that weren't unequivocally good and I can only think of maybe 3...

Nah! Only Time-Flight and that I still like.

Some of the more varied opinions I find tend to stem from Kinda, Castrovalva, Terminus, Arc of Infinity and Time-Flight. But if you grew up with them, it's fair to say you'll love any Peter Davison, partly for the nostalgia and partly for the sheer joy it enduces from the wonderfully charismatic man.

The 'beard' comment was splendidly in keeping with RTD's in-jokes too - a 'beard' being gay slang for a woman who pretends to be the partner of a gay man who wishes to appear straight (presumably because real beards both disguise and make men look more 'manly') - for example, see Nicole Kidman or Penelope Cruze.

So the line 'does he still have that stupid beard?', 'No - well, a wife' implies the Doctor knows something else about the Master we don't - or didn't!

I knew the minority at The Anorak Zone would piddle all over this...those guys are the ones Moffat targets, not I nor anyone else who actually has a life and can watch this series...

Time Crash! (Click here for planetzogblog review and other thoughts.)

Stu, you said:
"Tennant was certainly at the apogee of his Tennantness, but that just heightened the differences between them even as he listed the similarities. [Tennant]...he does spend a lot of time [1]making observations, [2]making fun, [3]turning on a dime in a crisis and [4]shouting which are things that Davison’s Doctor rarely did." (I've added numbers 1,2,3,4.)

Yeah, contrasts, similarites - that was the heart of Time Crash, wasn't it? The mini-episode began as an exercise in contrasts.

Chripy Tennant versus "Grumpy Davison" (copyright Moffat, Radio Times.)

Thing is - was Davo ever really grumpy?

Tennant even says he likes how he didn't have grumpy as a defining characteristic, at the end of the episode.

From your list, #4, shouting, that began the story on a strange footing, seeing Davo shouting.

#1, observations - actually, didn't Davo produce a fair stream of techno-babble-observations during his era?

#2, making fun. Davo was more subtle and wry, but he did tend to deflate people with humour.

#3, turning on a dime. Yeah, very much Tennant. Davo always deliberated.

Good review, Stu.
-----

Griffin, you said:
"I knew the minority at The Anorak Zone would piddle all over this..."

Do you mean to say "I knew the majority at The Anorak Zone would piddle all over this, who I suggest represent the minority of fans..."? Even that doesn't make sense. We Doctor Who fans are all individuals, though we are all fans.

Also, Moffat, far from dividing the fans into "good fans" and "bad fans", after his early "silly fans" misdirection, surely is being inclusive with his tribute to all fans (when Ten shows himself to be a big fan of Five at the end.)

"It’s a shame that Graham Harper didn’t receive an on-screen credit here"

Don't worry, he did: it's just after the opening title sequence.

Hi Stu.
You responded to my above comment, elsewhere (click for link to that elsewhere, planetzogblog) as Behind the Sofa was down temporarily, as you noted.

I've commented on your comment there... !

"I loved being you."

Yes!

"I loved being you."

Yes!

The comments to this entry are closed.

Categories
Doctor Who: Series One
Doctor Who: Series Two
Doctor Who: Series Three
Torchwood: Series One
Torchwood: Series Two
The Sarah Jane Adventures: Series One
The Eighth Doctor BBC7 Audios
The Eighth Doctor Novels
The Tenth Doctor Novels
Stripped Down Series 1
Stripped Down Series 2
Stripped Down Series 3
Stripped Down Series 4
Stripped Down Series 5
Stripped Down Series 6