« Sec The Builder | Main | No Sec Please, We're Human »

Apr 21, 2007

"We'll turn Manhattan, into an isle of joy..."

I'm not someone who tends to nitpick.  I really enjoyed last week's episode and it wasn't until later when I read some of the reviews that the inconsistencies and potential plot holes became apparent - and even then I don't think any of them spoiled it for me.  Because you know.  The Macra.  Sometimes I'll work through a rationalization for something or I'll simply let it go because the whole thing has been so damn entertaining.  I didn't even notice the character reading a copy of the Radio Times.

Unfortunately, I think I'm going to have to watch Daleks In Manhattan again because  about ten minutes in, a third of my brain was mildly distracted to such an extent that I think most of anything else nearly passed me by.  Here is the shot.  See if you can spot why …

… so bless her, Helen Raynor travels out to New York to research what it would have been like in the 1930s and produces some really poetic descriptions of how low people went and the extent to which humanity was for sale.  The design department work flat out to create Hooverville, this collection of tents and agony clinging together wondering how bad life can get.  The reliable Hugh Quarshie is producing a commanding performance as Solomon, the breaking of the bread symbolically replaying the choice his namesake had to make in the bible over a child and one third of my brain is thinking …

"Was that a football goal?  I suppose it must be if this was filmed in a park in Cardiff.  I wonder how they didn't notice that.  Did they notice it and decide it would have been too expensive to paint out?  Or did they just not notice right through filming to editing to colour timing to composing to well all of the other processes before it hit the screen.  But what if it wasn't a football goal.  I'll have to check it again when I've finished recording.  Just enjoy the episode.  But it could have been a soccer goal.  Perhaps it was supposed to be there.  Is this going to be the meme of the year - subliminal anachronisms across time?  What if soccer was quite popular in depression era New York - it's easier to play than American Football - you just need a large round ball.  Surely they would have played baseball.  Unless it was just something they didn't notice …"

Etc. Etc. 

Another third was distracted from the opening few minutes dealing with the consequences of the Radio Times cover in the real world.  Was it going to be the cliffhanger ending of the episode?  The Dalek/Human hybrid.  Had the production team sold out the big surprise ending for a magazine cover?  There was enough in the accompanying article to indicate that they had, but scuttle bug in the last couple of days suggested that actually it was smoke screen for some even greater shock.  It's a real shame then that in the end this turned actually to be the cliffhanger and gave the episode the same texture that The Sixth Sense had for me first time around having worked out the twist from the trailer.  So instead of asking 'Why're they doin' that?'  I was instead thinking 'They're doing that because of this.'

Luckily, since I have a decent brain capacity there was still enough juice in the other third to actually quite enjoy what was in essence a pretty old school slice of Doctor Who, a Hartnell story with production values.  The opening ten minutes featured exactly the kind of edutainment you might find in the opening episode of a Lucarroti-style historical with the Doctor revealing the era and its problems.  Its exactly what the series should be about - stepping into history having a look around.  In recent years a shorthand has crept into use in these situations, but for once the Doctor was actually given the chance to offer a lecture and it really helped to set the scene.

"The opening ten minutes featured exactly the kind of edutainment you might find in the opening episode of a Lucarroti-style historical with the Doctor revealing the era and its problems. "

Another trait of early Who was the grand shift between locations, the gang traveling across a world.  Then it was because they generally had to strike a set on a weekly basis and it meant that by sometimes changing everything they could add value.  Translating this story into a seven-parter, you could almost imagine 'Episode One - The Poor In Manhattan' 'Episode Two - The Sewer' 'Episode Three - A Dance With Death' and so on, the narrative generally staying on the Doctor and Martha except for the cutaways to Daleks.  And again, in keeping with those old stories, we knew who the main adversary was before the timelord, which is something that doesn't usually happen these days (I think Boomtown is an exception). 

The Doctor spent most of the story trying to discover who his adversary was, almost  dragged through through the story, being shown all of the plot details that need to be established ready for the Evolution of the Daleks.  In that way it did feel like the first proper Dalek story - for once they're not simply trying to blast their way to victory using sheer force but have instead a proper plan for their survival, even if it chucks out exactly who they are and all of the arguments they've had previously about being the supreme being just as they are.  I loved the moment when they actually paid lip service to this, rationalizing something which actually caused a war in the Eighth Doctor audio Blood of the Daleks.

Where the episode parted company with the earlier era was that with the exception of the aforementioned crossbar the sense of place was beautiful, the trip to New York for background plates being money well spent.  It's a pity that the budget wouldn't stretch to allowing up to see the travelers walking through the mass of the city but actually it seems right that the Doctor should stay on the edges in these kinds of stories, fitting into the gaps.  But the Empire State interiors with their art deco style were beautifully realised, as was the back stage of the theatre (shades of Weng Chiang actually).  I mean if you look at the costumes, its amazing what is actually being realised on a tv budget - the almost unrecognizable Miranda Raison sparkily making a perfect angel.

"It's a pity that the budget wouldn't stretch to allowing up to see the travelers walking through the mass of the city but actually it seems right that the Doctor should stay on the edges in these kinds of stories, fitting into the gaps."

And this was all tied together, not with a bit of stock music from the radio archives, but  with a wonderful score that just found the right balance between the more traditional incidental spots and the more evocative tracks; Murray Gold who I'm actually beginning to admire as a composer borrowing extensively from Woody Allen's playbook.  I love that the new series is confident enough to embrace contemporary music and it just seems perfect that the Tardis doors should open to the sound of Gershwin.  I do wonder what the whole episode would have been like had it been scored just like an Allen film but I can't think of any jazz music that could underscore the creepier moments featuring the pig blokes - and if you trying an drop in some faux-saxophones it can sound very jokey and very wrong.

But in the end, my favourite moment?  "They always survive, while I lose everything." 

See you next week, Helen.


I was getting whacking great Talons flashbacks last night, what with the period setting, the theatre, the sewers, the all-too-convenient and none-too-hygienic manhole cover in the theatre basement... Was rather hoping the cliffhanger would end up being Martha thrashing around in the water after being rugby-tackled by a pig slave, but no, there's Scaroth with fleshy dreadlocks.

Hooverville residents are LIARS. They are not poor, they have a football net for heaven's sake! :)

Nice to see that the gay agenda is kicked into touch, as the guy behind Martha is obviously having a Sherman over Martha. ;)


You mention the recent BBC7 Eighth Doctor story Blood of the Daleks exploring similar ideas - that of Dalek revulsion of perceived racial impurity.

With one of the motifs of the Tennant 2007 season being "blood" (I'm guessing), that BBC7 story seems now a strange foreshadowing of this season. (Though was it planned as such?)

The bronze Daleks in "Daleks in Manhattan" seem repulsed, but from the sixties onwards, the Daleks have always had a thing for mixing it up with humans: with implanting The Human Factor into Daleks in "Evil of...", to Davros using humans to grow new Daleks in "Revelation of...", to "Bad Wolf/The Parting of the Ways" and the harvested Earth.

The intolerant daleks in "Blood of the Daleks" seem to take their cue from the Daleks-as-fascists metaphor seen in "Remembrance of the Daleks".

Will there be mutiny in the ranks as the bronze lieutenants remember "Remembrance..." or will they chill out with thoughts of The Human Factor?

The comments to this entry are closed.

Doctor Who: Series One
Doctor Who: Series Two
Doctor Who: Series Three
Torchwood: Series One
Torchwood: Series Two
The Sarah Jane Adventures: Series One
The Eighth Doctor BBC7 Audios
The Eighth Doctor Novels
The Tenth Doctor Novels
Stripped Down Series 1
Stripped Down Series 2
Stripped Down Series 3
Stripped Down Series 4
Stripped Down Series 5
Stripped Down Series 6